The Collapse of Afghanistan: What Does It Mean to be Truly Free?

Aug 17, 2021
by Rabbi Nechemia Coopersmith

print article
The Collapse of Afghanistan: What Does It Mean to be Truly Free?

No matter how much money, power and resources are poured in, freedom and peace cannot be imposed by outside forces. It must come from within.


After 20 years of US military engagement and over a trillion dollars in training and equipping the Afghan army, the Taliban forces conquered the country in less than a week after America pulled out. It’s a shocking, appalling mess and there is plenty of blame to go around, but that’s above my pay grade. It’s not my place to discuss politics and foreign policy.

I want to focus on an important insight about liberty and freedom, and how it connects to Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year.

One of the glaring lessons in the collapse of Afghanistan is that no matter how much money, power and resources were poured in, freedom and peace cannot be imposed by outside forces. You can’t force someone to will something. It must come from within.

Some 640 passengers crammed into a US Air Force C-17 that flew from Kabul Airport to Qatar on August 15

Without the internal will to fight for independence and freedom, it’s no wonder the army folded and the president fled in the face of Taliban’s advance into Kabul. For 20 years, the enterprise in nation-building was being propped up by external forces. Once this ended, reality kicked in and it all came crashing down.

The same is true for our individual, personal freedom.

Who is the essential you?

Strip away all the external forces and elements that impact us, for good and bad, and what is left?

You are not your upbringing, your circle of friends, your title or position. You are not your wealth (or lack thereof), your looks, your hair, your intelligence, your fantasies, the color of your skin.

All of that forms the endless, complex strands that comprise the playing field of your life, but it’s not you. You are the chooser who determines how to respond to the moral challenge which is being presented to you at this instant. That choice is yours, and yours alone. You are personally responsible for your decision, whether it was wise or immoral, or not a decision at all. Because that’s you. You are that internal will.

Instead of blaming your parents, your spouse, the government, God or any other external force, switch gears and look inward. Focus on the only thing over which you do have control: your choice.

Everything else that exists outside of you is not you. You are not responsible for so much of the formative circumstances of your life. You are responsible for how you choose to respond to it. So instead of blaming your parents, your spouse, the government, God or any other external force, switch gears and look inward. Focus on the only thing over which you do have control: your choice.

You are not the baggage that was bequeathed to you by your upbringing, nor are you the brilliant IQ you happened to be born with. Those are some of the cards that the Almighty dealt you. Now it’s up to you to determine how you are going to play your hand. You are the sum total of your choices.

Abraham, the first forefather of the Jewish people, wasn’t blamed for worshipping idols as a child. He didn’t choose to be born at a time the entire world was seeped in idolatry. Nor was there any attempt to cover up his less-than-stellar upbringing. Submerged in darkness, he used his unique circumstances to find truth and chose greatness.

Rosh Hashanah Reality Check

Rosh Hashanah celebrates the birthday of humanity; it’s a celebration of free will. The Talmud teaches that in the moment of judgment, we stand before God utterly alone and come face to face with the reality of who we really are. All externals are stripped away. There are no friends to hide behind, no society to get lost in, no excuses to rely on, nor others to blame. It’s only the real you, all your heroic and selfish decisions, the dreams that were in reach but you left unfulfilled and the accomplishments you chose to attain.

The external forces we use to prop ourselves up or hide behind are pulled out and we are left with our true inner self that we are fully responsible for. That is who God is examining on Rosh Hashanah.

That reality check can be terrifying. It allows us to see what we are really made of.

But it’s also liberating and deeply meaningful. Recognizing that I am the only person responsible for attaining my personal greatness is like a blast of the shofar that pierces our soul, beckoning us to wake up and choose life.



Categories: Articole de interes general

2 replies

  1. Back then, when American troops entered Iraq, my father said: “None of the military equipment entered will return back to USA. It will be used to fight Israel.”

    Exactly this happened in Afghanistan. Mr. President Trump, wouldn’t have allowed that, but that is why he is not president anymore. My father died well before this… but we are very close to see Ezekiel 38 happening.

    https://www.digi24.ro/stiri/externe/prada-de-razboi-avioane-americane-arme-si-ochelari-cu-night-vision-au-ajuns-in-mainile-talibanilor-1639063

    Trebuia inventata scuza cu invalmaseala creata de asa zisa inaintare-fulger a talibanilor desculti. In aceste conditii, era evident ca nu au reusit la timp sa ia avioanele alea, sa le aduca pe jos la Kabul si sa le urce in avioanele de pasageri ca sa poata fi salvate… glumesc, dar chiar suna penibil.

    Toti stim (chiar si noi, outsider-ii) ce a insemnat adminsitratia Obama pentru Israel si Orientul Mijlociu. Administratia actuala este doar o continuare, multi spun ca Obama este Eminenta Cenusie – desigur, noi stim ca si el, ca si Biden acum, sunt doar marionete celor din spatele Democratilor.

    http://thetruereporter.com/was-the-afghanistan-crisis-planned/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: